DarkCat09/sb-vs-xray
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions

docs: add readme summarizing results

Browse source
This commit is contained in:
DarkCat09 2024-11-18 22:51:54 +04:00
parent ccf4281e7e
commit ddce7cd631
Signed by: DarkCat09
GPG key ID: BD3CE9B65916CD82
1 changed files with 67 additions and 0 deletions
Show stats Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

67
README.md Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,67 @@
# sing-box vs xray
An attempt on benchmarking these two multi-protocol proxying frameworks.
It's reproducible, configs are not redacted, I even uploaded self-signed TLS cert+key,
client commands are shown in `bench_*.txt` files.
All you need is iperf3 on client and server, hyperfine on client,
xray and sing-box binaries (take from "Releases" or compile by yourself) placed on client and server.
Results in a nutshell: (TODO)
## hyperfine, curl, direct outbound
Measurement of execution time of curl.
Shows overhead of a proxying software.
Proxies are set up to accept requests by SOCKSv5 and forward directly to net.
units: ms (less is better)
### ~1.5M binary file over https from dc09.ru
|proxy|min|avg|max|
|:----|:-:|:-:|:-:|
|no proxy|383.3|477.2|697.7|
|sing-box|376.4|478.6|681.2|
|xray|374.2|467.7|662.8|
### 162 bytes HTML over plain http from dc09.ru
|proxy|min|avg|max|
|:----|:-:|:-:|:-:|
|no proxy|51.0|60.5|81.7|
|sing-box|49.1|62.2|69.9|
|xray|51.2|61.6|76.4|
### ~150K HTML over https from github.com
|proxy|min|avg|max|
|:----|:-:|:-:|:-:|
|no proxy|365.3|402.1|449.8|
|sing-box|338.6|390.5|445.5|
|xray|342.3|390.8|426.0|
## iperf3, proxied outbound
Measurement of bandwidth with iperf3.
Shows processing speed of a proxying software.
Client proxy (sing-box or xray, specified by a table column) is connected to SOCKSv5, Trojan or VLESS inbound on dc09.ru;
server proxy on dc09.ru is either sing-box or xray (heading before a table), accepts requests on all 3 inbounds;
iperf3 server is on the same host as a server proxy.
units: Mbit/s (more is better)
### no proxy - `bench_iperf_direct.txt`
**sender** 93.7 Mbit/s (**receiver** 91.4 Mbit/s)
### server is sing-box - `bench_sb_*`
|protocol|sing-box|xray client|
|:-------|:------:|:---------:|
|SOCKSv5|102.0 (91.3)|102.0 (91.3)|
|Trojan|101.3 (91.0)|100.5 (90.6)|
|VLESS|101.3 (91.3)|101.5 (90.7)|
### server is xray - `bench_xray_*`
|protocol|sing-box|xray client|
|:-------|:------:|:---------:|
|SOCKSv5|101.5 (91.3)|103.0 (91.4)|
|Trojan|100.1 (90.0)|100.5 (90.6)|
|VLESS|99.6 (91.1)|102.0 (91.1)|